Are the Patriots working this time?
Iraq has now apparently fired some Scud missiles in the direction of Kuwait. (These are the same Scud missiles the Iraqis denied having. "Oh. You mean these Scud missiles"). It is being claimed that two have been shot down with American Patriot missiles. It is worth recalling that in the 1991 war the Americans initially claimed close to a 100% success rate at shooting down Scuds with Patriots, but in the months following the war the success rate claimed steadily dropped, ending up at less than 10%. As it happened, a major reason why the Scuds were exploding in mid air was simply that the second stage that the Iraqis had added to the Russian Scud missile (which is itself based on the German V-2 design - that's right, we are talking a World War 2 weapon here) was badly designed and built and the missiles had a tendency to break up by themselves.
Undoubtedly the Americans have in the twelve years since spent a lot of money improving the performance of the Patriot, and it will do better this time. However, one should always be sceptical of grandiose claims about its effectiveness. Shooting down missiles in flight is extremely hard.
Update: There is a good piece in Slate (and further links) talking about the failure of the Patriot missiles in 1991 and just how the new version has been supposedly improved from the old version. The attitude this time seems to be that the authors of the article will need to be shown pretty strong evidence before they believe the Patriots work.
I'm an Aussie presently living in London. This blog normally consists of my random thoughts on a variety of subjects, ranging from politics to telecommunications technology, movies cricket, urban design, beer, cheese, and whatever else comes into my head.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
►
2013
(4)
- ► 09/08 - 09/15 (2)
- ► 09/01 - 09/08 (1)
- ► 02/10 - 02/17 (1)
-
►
2012
(3)
- ► 02/05 - 02/12 (1)
- ► 01/29 - 02/05 (2)
-
►
2011
(20)
- ► 12/25 - 01/01 (1)
- ► 10/16 - 10/23 (1)
- ► 10/02 - 10/09 (2)
- ► 09/25 - 10/02 (1)
- ► 09/04 - 09/11 (2)
- ► 08/14 - 08/21 (2)
- ► 08/07 - 08/14 (1)
- ► 07/31 - 08/07 (1)
- ► 07/24 - 07/31 (1)
- ► 07/17 - 07/24 (1)
- ► 07/10 - 07/17 (2)
- ► 05/08 - 05/15 (1)
- ► 04/24 - 05/01 (1)
- ► 04/03 - 04/10 (1)
- ► 03/13 - 03/20 (1)
- ► 02/20 - 02/27 (1)
-
►
2010
(26)
- ► 12/19 - 12/26 (1)
- ► 12/05 - 12/12 (1)
- ► 10/31 - 11/07 (2)
- ► 10/03 - 10/10 (1)
- ► 09/12 - 09/19 (1)
- ► 08/22 - 08/29 (2)
- ► 07/25 - 08/01 (1)
- ► 07/04 - 07/11 (1)
- ► 05/23 - 05/30 (2)
- ► 05/16 - 05/23 (3)
- ► 04/04 - 04/11 (2)
- ► 03/14 - 03/21 (1)
- ► 03/07 - 03/14 (1)
- ► 02/28 - 03/07 (1)
- ► 02/21 - 02/28 (1)
- ► 02/14 - 02/21 (2)
- ► 01/10 - 01/17 (1)
- ► 01/03 - 01/10 (2)
-
►
2009
(13)
- ► 12/27 - 01/03 (1)
- ► 12/13 - 12/20 (2)
- ► 12/06 - 12/13 (1)
- ► 11/15 - 11/22 (1)
- ► 11/08 - 11/15 (1)
- ► 11/01 - 11/08 (2)
- ► 10/25 - 11/01 (1)
- ► 08/30 - 09/06 (1)
- ► 07/05 - 07/12 (1)
- ► 05/17 - 05/24 (1)
- ► 02/01 - 02/08 (1)
-
►
2008
(27)
- ► 12/28 - 01/04 (1)
- ► 07/20 - 07/27 (1)
- ► 06/29 - 07/06 (1)
- ► 06/22 - 06/29 (1)
- ► 05/18 - 05/25 (4)
- ► 05/04 - 05/11 (2)
- ► 04/27 - 05/04 (2)
- ► 04/13 - 04/20 (1)
- ► 04/06 - 04/13 (1)
- ► 03/30 - 04/06 (5)
- ► 03/09 - 03/16 (2)
- ► 03/02 - 03/09 (1)
- ► 02/24 - 03/02 (1)
- ► 02/10 - 02/17 (2)
- ► 02/03 - 02/10 (1)
- ► 01/27 - 02/03 (1)
-
►
2007
(121)
- ► 12/16 - 12/23 (1)
- ► 11/25 - 12/02 (2)
- ► 11/18 - 11/25 (1)
- ► 11/04 - 11/11 (1)
- ► 10/21 - 10/28 (1)
- ► 10/14 - 10/21 (2)
- ► 09/23 - 09/30 (1)
- ► 09/16 - 09/23 (3)
- ► 09/09 - 09/16 (1)
- ► 08/19 - 08/26 (1)
- ► 08/12 - 08/19 (2)
- ► 07/29 - 08/05 (2)
- ► 07/22 - 07/29 (2)
- ► 07/15 - 07/22 (4)
- ► 07/08 - 07/15 (5)
- ► 07/01 - 07/08 (4)
- ► 06/24 - 07/01 (10)
- ► 06/17 - 06/24 (5)
- ► 06/10 - 06/17 (5)
- ► 06/03 - 06/10 (3)
- ► 05/27 - 06/03 (5)
- ► 05/20 - 05/27 (4)
- ► 05/13 - 05/20 (2)
- ► 05/06 - 05/13 (2)
- ► 04/22 - 04/29 (8)
- ► 04/15 - 04/22 (1)
- ► 04/08 - 04/15 (6)
- ► 04/01 - 04/08 (6)
- ► 03/25 - 04/01 (12)
- ► 03/18 - 03/25 (10)
- ► 03/11 - 03/18 (8)
- ► 01/21 - 01/28 (1)
-
►
2006
(27)
- ► 12/17 - 12/24 (2)
- ► 09/24 - 10/01 (1)
- ► 07/16 - 07/23 (1)
- ► 07/09 - 07/16 (1)
- ► 06/25 - 07/02 (3)
- ► 06/18 - 06/25 (1)
- ► 03/26 - 04/02 (1)
- ► 03/05 - 03/12 (2)
- ► 02/26 - 03/05 (1)
- ► 02/19 - 02/26 (5)
- ► 02/12 - 02/19 (5)
- ► 02/05 - 02/12 (1)
- ► 01/22 - 01/29 (2)
- ► 01/08 - 01/15 (1)
-
►
2005
(117)
- ► 12/25 - 01/01 (1)
- ► 12/18 - 12/25 (1)
- ► 12/04 - 12/11 (1)
- ► 11/20 - 11/27 (1)
- ► 11/13 - 11/20 (1)
- ► 10/30 - 11/06 (2)
- ► 10/23 - 10/30 (1)
- ► 10/16 - 10/23 (7)
- ► 10/09 - 10/16 (1)
- ► 10/02 - 10/09 (4)
- ► 09/25 - 10/02 (4)
- ► 09/18 - 09/25 (2)
- ► 09/11 - 09/18 (4)
- ► 09/04 - 09/11 (5)
- ► 08/28 - 09/04 (3)
- ► 08/21 - 08/28 (2)
- ► 08/14 - 08/21 (2)
- ► 08/07 - 08/14 (1)
- ► 07/31 - 08/07 (2)
- ► 07/24 - 07/31 (1)
- ► 07/17 - 07/24 (5)
- ► 07/10 - 07/17 (2)
- ► 07/03 - 07/10 (2)
- ► 06/19 - 06/26 (1)
- ► 06/05 - 06/12 (1)
- ► 05/29 - 06/05 (3)
- ► 05/22 - 05/29 (3)
- ► 05/15 - 05/22 (1)
- ► 05/08 - 05/15 (1)
- ► 05/01 - 05/08 (2)
- ► 04/24 - 05/01 (2)
- ► 04/17 - 04/24 (5)
- ► 04/10 - 04/17 (2)
- ► 04/03 - 04/10 (2)
- ► 03/27 - 04/03 (3)
- ► 03/20 - 03/27 (5)
- ► 03/13 - 03/20 (2)
- ► 03/06 - 03/13 (6)
- ► 02/27 - 03/06 (3)
- ► 02/20 - 02/27 (2)
- ► 02/13 - 02/20 (2)
- ► 02/06 - 02/13 (3)
- ► 01/30 - 02/06 (2)
- ► 01/23 - 01/30 (3)
- ► 01/16 - 01/23 (3)
- ► 01/09 - 01/16 (2)
- ► 01/02 - 01/09 (3)
-
►
2004
(336)
- ► 12/26 - 01/02 (1)
- ► 12/19 - 12/26 (2)
- ► 12/12 - 12/19 (1)
- ► 11/14 - 11/21 (1)
- ► 11/07 - 11/14 (1)
- ► 10/10 - 10/17 (1)
- ► 10/03 - 10/10 (2)
- ► 09/19 - 09/26 (2)
- ► 09/12 - 09/19 (2)
- ► 09/05 - 09/12 (1)
- ► 08/29 - 09/05 (3)
- ► 08/22 - 08/29 (8)
- ► 08/15 - 08/22 (6)
- ► 08/08 - 08/15 (5)
- ► 08/01 - 08/08 (6)
- ► 07/25 - 08/01 (5)
- ► 07/18 - 07/25 (3)
- ► 07/11 - 07/18 (7)
- ► 07/04 - 07/11 (6)
- ► 06/27 - 07/04 (9)
- ► 06/20 - 06/27 (6)
- ► 06/13 - 06/20 (10)
- ► 06/06 - 06/13 (9)
- ► 05/30 - 06/06 (9)
- ► 05/23 - 05/30 (9)
- ► 05/16 - 05/23 (8)
- ► 05/09 - 05/16 (13)
- ► 05/02 - 05/09 (10)
- ► 04/25 - 05/02 (7)
- ► 04/18 - 04/25 (8)
- ► 04/11 - 04/18 (11)
- ► 04/04 - 04/11 (8)
- ► 03/28 - 04/04 (10)
- ► 03/21 - 03/28 (11)
- ► 03/14 - 03/21 (8)
- ► 03/07 - 03/14 (12)
- ► 02/29 - 03/07 (11)
- ► 02/22 - 02/29 (17)
- ► 02/15 - 02/22 (8)
- ► 02/08 - 02/15 (8)
- ► 02/01 - 02/08 (13)
- ► 01/25 - 02/01 (10)
- ► 01/18 - 01/25 (13)
- ► 01/11 - 01/18 (17)
- ► 01/04 - 01/11 (18)
-
▼
2003
(796)
- ► 12/28 - 01/04 (9)
- ► 12/21 - 12/28 (14)
- ► 12/14 - 12/21 (13)
- ► 12/07 - 12/14 (13)
- ► 11/30 - 12/07 (6)
- ► 11/23 - 11/30 (14)
- ► 11/16 - 11/23 (14)
- ► 11/09 - 11/16 (8)
- ► 11/02 - 11/09 (9)
- ► 10/26 - 11/02 (14)
- ► 10/19 - 10/26 (11)
- ► 10/12 - 10/19 (17)
- ► 10/05 - 10/12 (19)
- ► 09/28 - 10/05 (11)
- ► 09/21 - 09/28 (16)
- ► 09/14 - 09/21 (11)
- ► 09/07 - 09/14 (13)
- ► 08/31 - 09/07 (15)
- ► 08/24 - 08/31 (13)
- ► 08/17 - 08/24 (10)
- ► 08/10 - 08/17 (14)
- ► 08/03 - 08/10 (10)
- ► 07/27 - 08/03 (13)
- ► 07/20 - 07/27 (12)
- ► 07/13 - 07/20 (10)
- ► 07/06 - 07/13 (15)
- ► 06/29 - 07/06 (15)
- ► 06/22 - 06/29 (16)
- ► 06/15 - 06/22 (15)
- ► 06/08 - 06/15 (14)
- ► 06/01 - 06/08 (15)
- ► 05/25 - 06/01 (8)
- ► 05/18 - 05/25 (12)
- ► 05/11 - 05/18 (13)
- ► 05/04 - 05/11 (15)
- ► 04/27 - 05/04 (18)
- ► 04/20 - 04/27 (16)
- ► 04/13 - 04/20 (19)
- ► 04/06 - 04/13 (22)
- ► 03/30 - 04/06 (28)
- ► 03/23 - 03/30 (16)
-
▼
03/16 - 03/23
(29)
- Where is he now, then? The (London) Sunday Telegr...
- I think this speaks very well of the Americans, pe...
- It's a peculiar week For the last several years, ...
- Running the war and talking to the press do not re...
- My World Cup Final Preview England has idiotic li...
- What does this mean? There have been no attempts ...
- Is Saddam Dead?, and more on television news. As ...
- A total of ten missiles of various kinds have appa...
- Well fancy that The South African cricket team lo...
- Me too Yes, we got Bush talking about Medicare o...
- India through to final As it turned out, the rain...
- Skirmishes We have a clash between US Marines and...
- Mid-match update India scored an excellent 4/270 ...
- A peculiar interlude Clearly, a huge number of pr...
- World Cup second semi-final There has been a lot ...
- Are the Patriots working this time? Iraq has now ...
- Gas Alerts and the Like I am watching war coverag...
- Here we go Well, the war has started. It appears ...
- A nice quote (Darwin) was possessed of a very lar...
- There seem to have been a lot of great parts for a...
- Generation X, and journalists with few clues about...
- Australia through to final,and thoughts on "walkin...
- This is really scary. I haven't commented on the ...
- Dear Guardian editors. I would like to apply for y...
- First semi-final preview, undefeated World Cup win...
- More on Fuel Cells There is a good overview of t...
- Fuck You, Hansie Cronje (Yes, one isn't supposed ...
- And I could have seen "Far From Heaven" On Friday...
- Can someone tell me where I can get cheap and reli...
- ► 03/09 - 03/16 (16)
- ► 03/02 - 03/09 (28)
- ► 02/23 - 03/02 (23)
- ► 02/16 - 02/23 (21)
- ► 02/09 - 02/16 (21)
- ► 02/02 - 02/09 (15)
- ► 01/26 - 02/02 (24)
- ► 01/19 - 01/26 (22)
- ► 01/12 - 01/19 (13)
- ► 01/05 - 01/12 (18)
-
►
2002
(301)
- ► 12/29 - 01/05 (19)
- ► 12/22 - 12/29 (2)
- ► 12/15 - 12/22 (24)
- ► 12/08 - 12/15 (23)
- ► 12/01 - 12/08 (25)
- ► 11/24 - 12/01 (17)
- ► 11/17 - 11/24 (18)
- ► 11/10 - 11/17 (14)
- ► 11/03 - 11/10 (16)
- ► 10/27 - 11/03 (11)
- ► 10/20 - 10/27 (15)
- ► 10/13 - 10/20 (17)
- ► 10/06 - 10/13 (16)
- ► 09/22 - 09/29 (1)
- ► 09/15 - 09/22 (5)
- ► 09/08 - 09/15 (3)
- ► 09/01 - 09/08 (4)
- ► 08/25 - 09/01 (2)
- ► 08/18 - 08/25 (4)
- ► 08/04 - 08/11 (4)
- ► 07/28 - 08/04 (5)
- ► 07/21 - 07/28 (2)
- ► 07/14 - 07/21 (2)
- ► 07/07 - 07/14 (5)
- ► 06/30 - 07/07 (4)
- ► 06/23 - 06/30 (4)
- ► 06/16 - 06/23 (2)
- ► 06/09 - 06/16 (4)
- ► 06/02 - 06/09 (3)
- ► 05/26 - 06/02 (9)
- ► 05/19 - 05/26 (2)
- ► 05/12 - 05/19 (5)
- ► 04/21 - 04/28 (2)
- ► 04/14 - 04/21 (5)
- ► 04/07 - 04/14 (5)
- ► 03/31 - 04/07 (2)
No comments:
Post a Comment